Sunday, October 29, 2017

The death cult in comics

The estimable John C. Wright explains why Marvel and DC Comics are pursuing their present course:
What is happening is that the leaders at SJW Marvel would prefer to put Politically Correct nonsense and crap into bookstores for sale than real stories penned by good writers about heroic topics.

They do not know why. To them it looks like financial suicide.

I submit to your candid judgment that if you look at a man's financial motives, you are not seeing the whole man. Man seeks money to buy bread, but man does not live by bread alone. No culture in the history of the world ever existed without rites and rituals and sacrifice to hidden powers greater than human life. For the communist East, that power was the material dialectic of history, a sort of science flavored goddess, who demanded the bloody sacrifice of world wars, gulags, mass starvation, and endless executions. In the democratic West, the greater power was God, and, to a lesser degree, the ideals of freedom. God demands righteousness; democracy demands civic virtue and the self sacrifice of soldiers and sailors.

Now, no honest Christian would burn a pinch of incense to Caesar, and call him a god, for any amount of money. Not even the threat of death stirs the heart of the martyr.

SJW Marvel look at themselves as martyrs.

They think their goddess, history, will reward them with victory over their enemies, the conservatives, who are the sole source of all greed and evil in the world. All they need do is burn, degrade, and insult the beloved heroes of comics, and turn them all into minorities. The loss of review means nothing to them. They do not want our money.

They want the reward of righteousness without being righteous. They want to be martyrs without paying the cost in blood. Political correctness allows them to do this. All they need do it take an industry and ruin it in the name of PC.

The destruction is deliberate. They regard it as a sacrifice. This is a death cult.
The retailers, on the other hand, signed up for no such sacred mission and they are extremely unhappy with it.
An exchange between direct market retailers and Marvel Comics editors became heated in the closing minutes of Marvel’s Retailer-Only panel at New York Comic Con 2017, starting after a unidentified retailer expressed concern about Marvel’s lenticular variants not selling well in his store.

Marvel executive editors Tom Brevoort and Nick Lowe fielded the question, thanking the obviously upset retailer for his feedback. However, the retailer cut Lowe short to express his distaste for Marvel’s recent trend of replacing or altering its existing characters.

The retailer specifically cited examples such as characters that don’t reflect the ethnicity, gender, or sexuality of their predecessors – specifically expressing his distaste for Iceman “kissing other men,” and Thor “becoming a woman.” The retailer’s complaints sparked an outcry among the other retailers present in the room, some echoing his frustration, with multiple attendees raising their voices to speak over each other.

The original speaker called for “creating new characters and not messing with the old guys. The old guys are solid,” while a second said that Marvel has “never replaced its characters like this.”

Lowe pointed out that the changing nature of the identities of characters was engrained in Marvel’s history, pointing out examples from James Rhodes to Frog Thor. The retailer responded that Marvel has “never replaced them all at once before,” going on to say that he has had Marvel Cinematic Universe fans come into his store to find Avengers comic books only to leave “when they see that Thor is a woman and Captain America is a black man.”
And what's more, the social justice cancer has spread to the Marvel movies now.
The rot of Marvel Comics has finally crept into the Marvel Cinematic Universe. Not just the rot of Social Justice -- the rot of mediocrity.

On paper the movie sounds awesome. Thor, the God of Thunder, must defend Asgard and the Nine Realms from Hela, the all-powerful Goddess of Death. However, he is stranded on the planet of Sakaar on the other side of the galaxy. Surviving a brutal gladiatorial arena, Thor gathers allies and makes his way home to prevent Ragnarok, the prophesized destruction of Asgard.

In execution, it was as stale as week-old popcorn. With a basic plot, forgettable dialogue and limp characters, I struggled to remain engaged with the movie, much less care about the story. The heart of the problem lies with the movie's poor craftsmanship and its rejection of the mythic.
Well, that's certainly interesting, don't you think? I don't know about you, but I love the smell of opportunity in the morning.

Labels: , ,


Blogger Cataline Sergius October 29, 2017 10:31 AM  

Any chance John will write for Alt Hero?

Blogger Silly but True October 29, 2017 10:40 AM  

Too on the nose for a fat hero named Wildcard whose superpower is to rape people... twice?

Blogger Hugo Smith October 29, 2017 10:40 AM  

Meanwhile, he takes shots at the alt-right.

Blogger VD October 29, 2017 10:40 AM  

We've discussed it. Chuck Dixon and I have it covered for the present, but if things continue to go well, I would very much like to do a Moth & Cobweb series.

Anonymous aegis-1080 October 29, 2017 10:41 AM  

Literal death cult, if more Boomers decide to go full jihad Paddock-style.

Blogger James Dixon October 29, 2017 10:43 AM  

Marvel and DC think their distribution networks and contracts will protect them from competition. Hollywood thinks along similar lines wrt to their movies. They're both wrong.

Blogger VD October 29, 2017 10:44 AM  

Meanwhile, he takes shots at the alt-right.

So what? How many of the people reading this now agreed with me back in 2004 when I was slamming George W. Bush and he was riding high in the polls?

People understand things in their own time and on their own schedule, if they ever do. First, John is on the side of Christianity and Western Civilization. Second, John's talent is such that I could not care less what his politics happen to be. I'd publish China Mieville or William Gibson in a heartbeat too. We already publish Martin van Creveld and Steve Keen, neither of whom are men of the Right.

Anonymous Steve October 29, 2017 10:47 AM  

AWAKE IN THE NIGHT LAND would make an awesome graphic novel.

Blogger Hugo Smith October 29, 2017 10:48 AM  

So what? He purposefully works to slander his audience.

Who liked you better than Bush? I don't know or care.

Blogger Sam Spade October 29, 2017 10:49 AM  

John C. Wright is brilliant and he seems like an honest man.

Blogger Brad Matthews October 29, 2017 10:49 AM  

There were 2 comic stores in our town. Now there is only a game store. Don't know if they sell comics.

Blogger Vlad October 29, 2017 10:51 AM  

In the Thor movies, Heimdall is black and now Valkyrie is black. Norse gods not looking Nordic? Only in SJW land

Anonymous Looking Glass October 29, 2017 10:53 AM  

@4 VD

Considering the nature of Children's & YA literature, converting the better series into Graphic Novels is a fascinating synergy for Castalia. I'm also really curious if there's a potential GN into Novel audience. Sort of a one-shot or short-series Graphic Novels as an introduction to the books.

Blogger wreckage October 29, 2017 10:56 AM  

I was saying the other day the scariest thing about the SJW and a whole segment of the Left is that they believe that because they are right, there will be no consequences. They believe their moral/feelz/rightness overrides plain facts.

JCW is too kind to them. They do not expect to be martyred; they do not think they CAN be martyred; they expect to FEEL martyr-y and get the accolades for martyrdom and then everything will work out nicely for them because they are good.

Every other religious and political fanatic has understood that there are consequences, and accepted them. The SJW does not believe in consequences or costs.

Anonymous Looking Glass October 29, 2017 10:56 AM  

Speaking of Alt-Hero,at 100k there were some fun "Quad Damage" jokes to be made, but can anyone think of an 11x multiplier in anything semi-common in gaming? A-H clearly has worked up the combo meter.

Blogger wreckage October 29, 2017 10:57 AM  

@4 Oh, wow. Yes, oh golly, goodness and heavens yes. JCW in a format my kids can digest? Yessssssssss.

To add moral weight to my pleading, I respected the swear rules.

Anonymous TS October 29, 2017 10:59 AM  

Vox are you going to go VR with the comics?

Blogger mark auld October 29, 2017 11:02 AM  

Z mans latest post is about the death cult the churchians have become. Sjw's kill what ever venue they enter.

Anonymous Mr. Rational October 29, 2017 11:03 AM  

Speaking of A-H, both the total and the backer count are still going up.  $225,988.00 and 2019.

Sure would be nice to have a countdown to closure.

Anonymous Brick Hardslab October 29, 2017 11:05 AM  

If Castalia Comics is too be more than a brilliant flash in the pan it will need ongoing stories and dedicated creators. Moth and Cobweb would be an excellent addition.

But no reason to stop there. There are plenty of brilliant artists and writers who are not working because of the nature of the business. The kind of guys who are doing commissions while they work a day job. They dream of steady work but know if they work for the wrong people or support the wrong viewpoint they'll never play for the big leagues.

If CC can crack the distribution problem it can challenge that and make comics a real thing again and not a fading fringe.

Blogger Dave October 29, 2017 11:15 AM  

I would very much like to do a Moth & Cobweb series.

This would be a fantastic candidate for crowd funding. It wouldn't reach the epic height of the Alt Hero campaign but it would keep you cash positive and indicate the demand. More experience running crowd funders wouldn't hurt either.

Steve wrote:AWAKE IN THE NIGHT LAND would make an awesome graphic novel.

Great idea.

Blogger Resident Moron™ October 29, 2017 11:17 AM  

Mr Wright is neither ignorant nor deliberately dishonest. He’s animated against the altRight because various commentators here disparaged his patchwork family in cuckoo terms.

But his inability to separate the wheat from the chaff due to emotional factors is a problem all men share.

Blogger L' Aristokrato October 29, 2017 11:17 AM  

It's pretty simple, really.

SJW types have their sense of identity built around their ideology. As such, they're activists for it, first and foremost, and anything else is incidental.
I this case, it just so happens the task is to make comics, only as pointed out above, to the SJW involved, they are activists first, storytellers second; If that even factors at all.

They are not aiming for failure, nor martyrdom.
To the contrary, they'd love nothing more than to rub success in people's faces, should they ever get the chance to do it. Its just that they would almost never willingly sacrifice pushing their ideology for the sake of that success.

In the case of comics in particular, the issue has been aggravated by the fact that neither Marvel, nor DC have had to succumb to the whims of the market, as they are both banked by Disney/Warner, and thus unable to fail on their own.

Anonymous M. C. Tuggle October 29, 2017 11:25 AM  

Odd how Ragnorak featured Nordic gods portrayed by Blacks, but the kingdom of Wakanda in Black Panther has nary a White face.

Blogger Nate Winchester October 29, 2017 11:27 AM  

Seconded. (Especially after reading his superman pitch.)

Blogger pyrrhus October 29, 2017 11:27 AM  

What it comes down to is that the twitching of the SJW's amygdala is always the most important thing in her life. They have survived in the West primarily because the Central Banks have prevented reality from impinging on their mental illness by funding both people and corporations that are completely disfunctional and bleed money from every pore...When will it end? There's no knowing, but it will end.

Blogger Nate Winchester October 29, 2017 11:27 AM  

I'd also vote for his "count to..." series is natural for comics.

Blogger VD October 29, 2017 11:33 AM  

Sure would be nice to have a countdown to closure.

Yes, but given that it is a weekend and the developers have not been particularly swift, I would not anticipate one. C'est la vie, the campaign has been incredibly successful and the platform has proven up to the task despite the occasional problem.

Blogger VD October 29, 2017 11:36 AM  

If CC can crack the distribution problem it can challenge that and make comics a real thing again and not a fading fringe.

We are working on it. We've already spoken with one big player who has expressed interest in some of our ideas.

Blogger VD October 29, 2017 11:38 AM  

So what? He purposefully works to slander his audience.

Your very next comment proves that you know you were overstating your case.

"This is a quote from his blog. He is either a liar or ignorant."

Then obviously you cannot assert that he is purposefully engaged in slander. As it happens, John Wright is not a liar. He is mistaken, to be sure, perhaps due to ignorance, but I can attest he is not purposefully lying.

Regardless, Mr. Wright's opinions are not the topic here. And all attempts to sow dissension here will be met swiftly with bans. Don't try it again. I'm not even remotely interested in "Jenny, did you hear what Emily said about Suzy" drama.

Anonymous JC NRA October 29, 2017 11:44 AM  


Speaking of angry retailers and distribution channels - when the time comes, will you have some marketing literature that we Ilk can take to local shops? There's a shop near me, and one in my hometown that I'd be happy to hit. Not sure about their politics, so a "make comics great again" approach might resonate more than explaining to them what Alt Right means ... but I'm sure their numbers suck and they would embrace Alt Hero. I'd be honored to help push this from a grass roots level.

Blogger Rez Zircon October 29, 2017 11:48 AM  

Not so long before some retailers decide it's not worth the shelf fees to retain Marvel products. [Assuming it's like other retail, where the store pays to have a given brand in their lineup.]

Opportunity indeed.... just about the time Alt-Hero is ready for retail. [Especially if there are no shelf fees.]

Blogger pyrrhus October 29, 2017 11:54 AM  

Wright's other preoccupation is taking shots at the Alt-Right, usually very incoherent shots indicating his emotions have taken over....

Blogger pyrrhus October 29, 2017 11:57 AM  

@32 In most retail, like grocery stores, it's the manufacturer who pays fees to the store to get stocked and get better locations for its products on the shelves. I have never heard of a retailer paying....

Blogger Matt October 29, 2017 12:00 PM  

Comics industry produces 2, maybe 3, good comics per year. Its been like that for over 20 years. If its not an SJW writing utter trash, its a perverse 40 yr old man inserting his sexual fantasies into what used to be an illustrated episodic magazine for children.

Anonymous Mr. Rational October 29, 2017 12:01 PM  

@28 That's why I said "sure would be nice" rather than "this thing is useless without".

Frustrating, though.  This is the kind of thing I used to do in my sleep.  They didn't even put in any mouseover text with the termination date/time in GMT.

Ah, well, back to trying to draw stuff in Microsloth Paint.

Anonymous kfg October 29, 2017 12:13 PM  

"They do not want our money."

As a nuanced side note however, as socialists, they believe they are earning their salaries by taking down the industry, as that's what they are there to do.

When they have sucked the life out of this particular host they will simply transfer to, and draw a salary from, some other victim host.

Blogger Howard Stone October 29, 2017 12:14 PM  

First issues will be collectors items for sure, especially for those who signed up for limited covers.

Anonymous Man of the Atom October 29, 2017 12:15 PM  

Looking Glass wrote:@4 VD

Considering the nature of Children's & YA literature, converting the better series into Graphic Novels is a fascinating synergy for Castalia. I'm also really curious if there's a potential GN into Novel audience. Sort of a one-shot or short-series Graphic Novels as an introduction to the books.

The conversion of JCW, Rod Walker, and Vox's material to graphic novel format would give Castalia several years of great content for graphic novels -- don't edit down, but serialize away! Thumbs up on that one!

Blogger Chiva October 29, 2017 12:17 PM  

SJW Marvel look at themselves as martyrs.
Not martyrs, but as 'Heroes' ready to lay other people's money on the line.

Blogger tz October 29, 2017 12:21 PM  

The only thing worse than secular atheism is secular paganism. It IS a death cult, but only in the sense that reality is ignored. They engage in ritual sacrifice, and will wonder why everything is going to hell.
The foundation of Western Civilization is Christ, Truth incarnate, and Truth in general. That is why it was accepted that the earth went around the sun and the whole scientific revolution.

It is too easy for Man to take some wild opinion and not subject it to the test of reason and evidence. That is why the French Revolution ended in the reign of terror. The US had a "Natural Law" tradition and was suspicious of power and even their own ideas.

The SJWs are true believers in a lie. MLKjr said to judge based on the content of one's character. Technically they do, but having multiple children out of wedlock is no longer a sin, bizarre sexual practices (with consent?) aren't, even violence and vandalism aren't sins. Only racism, sexism, etc. are, at least if you don't give enough tribute to Planned Parenthood. Or are the equivalent of the priesthood - Bill Clinton and Harvey Weinstein - they could literally rape women while talking about the problem of sexual harassment.

The Pagan mush the SJWs are doing is worse on several levels. First there is no real heroism - nor villany. They've bought into relativism except for virtue signalling on the X-isms.

There is one danger for the alternative. Christendom requires Christian values. Even some right-wing media wants to load up stories with sexual situations and profanity. Generally I don't see how any storyline should worry about a gay character (they aren't busy saving the world), but similarly hookups. Even the old Pagans had better virtues. Family values includes patriotism (nationalism), but also courage, prudence, temperance, and justice.

The not so subtle shift is to see marriage and family as boring. The heroes aren't sacrificing, nobless oblige, they get to do all the cool stuff while the squares go about their boring lives.

Blogger Lovekraft October 29, 2017 12:40 PM  

This isn't hard to figure out, and no amount of deflection on the part of the progressives will change this fact: we don't want to be shamed and guilt-tripped into reading about the struggles of other identity groups, while at the same time being portrayed as the villains.

I want to read an story about a young caucasian male growing up in Europe as his culture is attacked by Euro authoritarians, jihadis, no-go zones etc. I want to read about how he perseveres in the face of random racist attacks on him. I want to read about how he takes on and defeats the identity politics crowd, in allegorical terms that is.

We also have struggles and have no interest in suppressing our own challenges for the sake of diversity.|

TLDR: the left has overplayed their hand, have hijacked our icons instead of creating their own and letting them sink or swim on their own merit.

Blogger Lovekraft October 29, 2017 12:43 PM  

@12 Vlad: "now Valkyrie is black"

I had to google that. Unbelievable. Saw the trailer and wondered, who's this broad? Valkyrie, in the comics, was a white as they come.

Blogger tuberman October 29, 2017 12:45 PM  

There are many Comics Stores in my area, so it would be great to discuss the Store business side of things to help talk to these people. It looks like there is about 25 stores within a 40 mile range, and perhaps more.

Anonymous BBGKB October 29, 2017 12:47 PM  

Literal death cult, if more Boomers decide to go full jihad Paddock-style.

Its bad enough boomtards let jews loot the US.

Blogger End the Witchhunt of Harvey Weinstein October 29, 2017 12:49 PM  

If Alt-Hero is successful, expect Marvel and DC to use their old trick and sue under copyright law.

Anonymous DaveA October 29, 2017 12:51 PM  

Virtue-signaling is a form of conspicuous consumption, ostentatiously wasting resources to show everyone how wealthy you are.

Wealthy people and organizations each do many things, but they always have one activity, rarely two, that is massively cash-flow-positive (e.g. Google Adwords, Microsoft Office) and pays for all the others. If virtue-signaling is allowed to interfere with that one thing...

Blogger swiftfoxmark2 October 29, 2017 12:52 PM  

The Thor movies have always been the weak link in the Marvel Filmverse. The second one, especially, was forgettable.

I don't listen to critics though. I've been watching the Inhumans show lately and it's been pretty decent. The villain, Maximus, even made disparaging remarks about Black Bolt's "meritocracy".

Blogger artensoll October 29, 2017 12:59 PM  

40. Chiva: "SJW Marvel look at themselves as martyrs.
Not martyrs, but as 'Heroes' ready to lay other people's money on the line."

I've read several accounts in the last 6 months written by ex-SJWs. They all say they saw themselves as a kind of Superhero, swooping in to save the 'oppressed'.

Anonymous SciVo de Plorable October 29, 2017 12:59 PM  

VD wrote:We've discussed it. Chuck Dixon and I have it covered for the present, but if things continue to go well, I would very much like to do a Moth & Cobweb series.

Please make sure to keep his habit of (like me) using a word's size as a proxy of its ease. I love that he tosses around "proffer" and "snood" and whatnot. Keep it! Kids need to learn their words.

Blogger Mr.MantraMan October 29, 2017 1:09 PM  

Basically womanish behavior.

Anonymous Man of the Atom October 29, 2017 1:09 PM  

"Ash can" versions of a comic issue, or containing samples of many comics, would be familiar to retailers and comic buyers. Sometimes these are newsprint or bond paper, and can be 5"x8" saddle-stapled or full-sized comic mags. Normally about 12-18 total pages.

Blogger VD October 29, 2017 1:23 PM  

If Alt-Hero is successful, expect Marvel and DC to use their old trick and sue under copyright law.

Then the Legal Legion of Evil will go into action and we'll crowdfund a legal assault on every weak spot we can find. You KNOW those companies are not even remotely clean.

Blogger Roger G2 October 29, 2017 1:26 PM  

“That smell, that gasoline smell. Smells like...victory.”
Well done, VD. It’s a cool thing to watch as the SJW’s shriek in utter shock and horror.
Alt-Hero is going to do for American comics culture what the Trumpslide did for our culture in general.

Anonymous Cyclone Bob October 29, 2017 1:27 PM  

M.C.Tuggle: Odd how Ragnorak featured Nordic gods portrayed by Blacks, but the kingdom of Wakanda in Black Panther has nary a White face.

It's already planned for the sequel. Batman and Wonder Shiksa steal Wakanda's national treasure, Tha 1488-carat Jujustone, and the country collapses into despair, malaise and ruination. Black Flight ensues; and Western honkeys buy up the empty mansions - all built by noble black hands - for pennies on the shekel.

Then the black heroes - Black Panffer, Norbit, Madea, and Harriett Butman - fly in on their hypersonic magic pyramids to fight off the intruders and end the gentrification (a codeword for Black Genocide).

Rolling next to the end credits, there's a celebratory BBQ to shame that pathetic Ewok party, and Tyler Perry's fatsuit kampfs Eddie Murphy's fatsuit for the last chicken wing. Eddie wins by farting in Perry's open mouth (he's a mouth-breever), and shouts Herca-leez! Herca-leez! Aybah laughs, but then Madea pulls a Glock out her titties and busts a cap in his ass. Then Harriett Butman picks up the chicken wang and gets the last, most-satisfying bite. Then she sucks the sauce off Norbit's stubby fat fingers. That was awkward for everyone.

Anonymous Brick Hardslab October 29, 2017 1:33 PM  

That's fantastic. I suspected there were more big names out there who wanted to make good comics I just never thought you'd hear from them so quickly

Anonymous Eli October 29, 2017 1:39 PM  

Why not simply talk to Mr. Wright in email instead of talking about him in a comment thread that he has nothing to do with. As for Marvel movies from here on out expect more sjw story lines. The latest Thor movie director specifically wanted to add more diversity to the film from the get go. From here on I suspect the future of Marvel films to get much worse. We already know their comics are awful.

Blogger Markku October 29, 2017 1:53 PM  

Marvel and DC have already been beaten in court by an indie over "superhero".

Blogger WynnLloyd October 29, 2017 1:54 PM  

That's probably why they freaked out so much after the election. There were consequences to their alienating the core population, and they were forced to face them for the first time.

Blogger James Dixon October 29, 2017 1:55 PM  

> The SJW does not believe in consequences or costs.

While true, some of them are learning. Kathy Griffin, Jamele Hill, etc. There will be more.

> "Alt-Retard demonstrates 'Ban by Vox'." Film at 11.

Yeah, I'd say that was the final straw.

Anonymous kfg October 29, 2017 1:57 PM  

"Valkyrie, in the comics, was a white as they come."

Go figure.

So, when do we get the white Shaka Zulu heroically fending off the black northers?

Blogger Heian-kyo Dreams October 29, 2017 1:59 PM  

Benjamin Cheah's review of Thor: Ragnorak confirmed my thoughts that Valkyrie shows up in the movie to be a strong independent black womyn and sneer at Thor. No thanks.

The rest of the movie sounds like a muddled mess.

Anonymous Man of the Atom October 29, 2017 2:14 PM  

Heian-kyo Dreams wrote:Benjamin Cheah's review of Thor: Ragnorak confirmed my thoughts that Valkyrie shows up in the movie to be a strong independent black womyn and sneer at Thor. No thanks.

The rest of the movie sounds like a muddled mess.

Obviously, since you are already going to these films, you'll suck down whatever SJW pablum they offer. And you'll like it! Ergo, heap it on, sister!

One of the telling things about Hollyweird and the MU is that Thor is just another "space guy", not a god. A god might have something to say about morality, ethics, and justice. "Good" and "Evil" might come into discussion; can't have that.

Might be hitting too close to home for some.

"Paging Mr Weinstein! Mr Weinstein to the courtesy phone!"

Blogger Lovekraft October 29, 2017 2:25 PM  

@ 53 VD: "You KNOW those companies are not even remotely clean."

We have Cernovich, who mentioned in a recent podcast of how eager he would be to be sued so that he could, in the discovery process, turn over every stone they want untouched.

Anonymous kfg October 29, 2017 2:27 PM  

Taika Waititi on casting a 5'4" black girl to play a 6' Viking Shieldmaiden:

"Just because the character was blonde and white in the comic book. That doesn’t matter. That’s not what [that character] is about.' People forget that. Die-hard fans will say, 'That’s not really authentic to the comics,' but as soon as they watch the movie, and they’re involved in the story, and actually what’s happening, everybody forgets . . .Unless it’s the topic of the film, it just shouldn’t even be — what do we even care? I think the story is king, and you want the best person for the job. And Tessa tested against — we cast a very broad net, and Tess was the best person.""

On possibly directing Akira:

"But as movies like Ghost in the Shell have cast white performers in adaptations of Japanese works, the concern for whitewashing remains prevalent. Waititi ensures IGN that this will not be the case.

"Yeah. Actually Asian teenagers would be the way to do it for me and probably no, not, like no name, I mean sort of unfound, untapped talent.""

Blogger Markku October 29, 2017 2:48 PM  

I heard a pretty good argument for casting Johansson for Mira: She's not actually a human being, she's an android. And if you look at how Japanese draw humans in animes and mangas, they don't look Japanese at all. They look western, or at least no particular ethnicity. So, if they had complete freedom to design an android, then Johansson might well be what they would have designed.

Blogger Sillon Bono October 29, 2017 2:50 PM  

@64 I watched the movie last Friday, it is revolting that Cate Blanchett doesn't get more screen time, instead we get sassy mulato womyn down our throats, Thor can match Hulk but is defeated by sassy mulato womyn, in fact evey being in the movie is kicked by sassy mulato womyn, the funniest bit is when you realise that she serves no purpose at all to the story and there is no reason for her to be in the movie.

Loki's interaction with sassy mulato womyn made me really angry... (I do not want to spoil the movie)

Blogger Markku October 29, 2017 2:50 PM  

She was also designed to be an international operative. All the more reason to make her look generic instead of clearly Japanese.

Anonymous Looking Glass October 29, 2017 3:11 PM  

@66 Markku

Anime & Manga designs are intentionally generalized so they have a wider appeal, though not explicitly outside of Japan. At least in the early days. (People forget that Northern & Southern Japanese do have slightly different features, even if the country's population is dominated by Edoites.) While the style is distinctively Japanese, the characters really aren't. (Though, really, that's mostly due to speed reasons than anything Globalist.)

ScarJo was the right choice for the Major, though the movie was always going to suffer from Hollywood thinking it's an action movie. Ghost in the Shell properties are always far more Blade Runner in nature, thus some form of Techno-Thriller. It really doesn't work for a Big Budget movie.

Last little point, and something no Japanese will ever admit publicly, but they view themselves as fair-skinned. Something they look down on the other East Asians over, so ScarJo was never going to bother them. They viewed is positively, but it was something for the SJWs to make a fuss about.

Blogger tublecane October 29, 2017 3:11 PM  

They may worship Death in real life or on comics, though I don't think they realize it on either case. They produced material no one wants to read because they must. That's what they do.

But is it a case of "keep SJW-ing, though the heavens fall?" Or in their heart of hearts do they imagine sales will rebound any day because they're right, dangit?

Blogger Markku October 29, 2017 3:19 PM  

Last little point, and something no Japanese will ever admit publicly, but they view themselves as fair-skinned.

A bit more specifically, they view fairness of skin as the most important sign of privilege. Because they have a skin type that tans extremely quickly. So, if your skin is white, it means you have never worked on a field. This is why geishas paint their faces completely white.

Blogger Markku October 29, 2017 3:21 PM  

Amusingly, when my sister was in Japan the first time, she saw a procession of geishas from a geisha school. She was with Japanese friends at the time, who told her that this is such a rare sight that Japanese usually go through their lives without seeing a single geisha in training.

Blogger Markku October 29, 2017 3:24 PM  

They were all like, this did NOT just happen to someone who only just stepped her foot in Japan the first time...

Blogger Markku October 29, 2017 3:42 PM  

It's like, we Finns have been telling Americans all our lives that no, there are no polar bears in Finland. Like, at all. Then, one escapes from a zoo, and the first thing an American sees when going to town, is a polar bear walking down the street.


Blogger LP9 October 29, 2017 3:52 PM  

Undeniable Wonderful Clarity I adore so many at CH producing, hardworking, I am very very proud of everyone!

Always know you have immense support

Anonymous Looking Glass October 29, 2017 3:53 PM  

@74 Markku

Given the amount of tourists certain places get, the "it's only happened once!" events invariably have an American standing there by sheer dumb luck.

Blogger Heian-kyo Dreams October 29, 2017 4:10 PM  

That's why my involuntary movie theater boycott continues...

What Waititi says would be uplifting if the script gave Valkyrie anything to do other than grrrrrl power.

Blogger Emmanuel Mateo-Morales October 29, 2017 4:47 PM  

"The heart of the problem lies with the movie's poor craftsmanship and its rejection of the mythic."

And that sums up a good deal of the Marvel Cinematic Universe in a nut shell and ALL of the Thor movies. Clark's Law (more like often uncritically swallowed maxim, but whatever), not really magical at all Alien versions of Marvel 616 Asgard is BOOOOOOOORRRRRRRRIIIIIIIINNNNNNNNGGGGGG, especially since they didn't even have the common courtesy when designing the MCU to AT LEAST make heavy hitters like Thor and Hulk city busters, not even high block busters or building busters!

Say what you want about the DCEU, and there's plenty of things to loathe, but at least they didn't fucking make Wondie, as much as many here may hate feminism, and the Olympians into Clark's Law Aliens. They kept them fuckig' Greek pagan gods (even if from what little we know about them in the DCEU, they're considerably less powerful than their real life or any given mainstream comic universe counterparts) and kept Diana an Amazon.
Though... I did hear that one of the ideas floated around for years after Man of Steel was released was to make Wondie Kryptonian, which was about the only thing I agreed was retarded with one of my feminist class mates in college, but hey, at least the film makers realized this was stupid and didn't go THAT direction.

Also, the DCEU just has all around better action scenes and action direction. Like, no contest... aside from the shaky cam. I have yet to see, in live action films, a better superhero cinematic universe that adequately captures the raw power and scope of its heroes so well and viscerally... Suicide Squad not withstanding. Oh sure, there are more powerful cinematic superhero verses, but not that really hit home just how momentously mighty the characters on screen truly are. It really makes me wish Thor and Hulk were a lot less metro-sexually emasculated in comparison.

I mean, just look at this charge here between Hulk and Abomination, two peer level opponents that you THINK would cause more collateral to show you how much more energy they're releasing in the actual collision itself:

And compare it to a similar charge between Superman and Zod, who are also peer level opponents:

Night and day on the power scale! And the epic scale!

Anonymous Brick Hardslab October 29, 2017 6:07 PM  

There's a scene in one of the Zaitoichi movies where he says, "I have skin as white as a prince," or something to that effect.

Blogger Lovekraft October 29, 2017 6:08 PM  

@67 Sillan Bono: "when you realise that she serves no purpose at all to the story"

IMDB has been surprisingly lenient in allowing several of my recent movie/tv show reviews to go through. I am slowly turning up the heat, so to speak, and I suspect that my shredding of race-switching Valkyrie may end up getting me banned (yet again lolz).

Blogger Emmanuel Mateo-Morales October 29, 2017 7:33 PM  


Go ahead. Spoil it. We all can already see a lot of the things going on in it and I'm not going to waste money to see it. I'll just get it on bootleg if I even want to watch it.

Blogger Emmanuel Mateo-Morales October 29, 2017 7:40 PM  


Hypocrisy, much.

Blogger Emmanuel Mateo-Morales October 29, 2017 7:40 PM  


Wait? What pitch? What pitch?

Blogger Emmanuel Mateo-Morales October 29, 2017 7:53 PM  


"It surprised me that people who spend their money at comic cons and read about heroes are so afraid and un-heroic in their own code to stand for something."

No, that's just how most people who are fans of something featuring people who are better them (or, at least, supposed to be) tend to be. That's not surprising. That's like saying water is wet.

Blogger Emmanuel Mateo-Morales October 29, 2017 7:57 PM  


They're about as clean as Yungbluth or whatever that loser's name is.

Blogger Emmanuel Mateo-Morales October 29, 2017 7:59 PM  


You know, I kinda they do try and sue you. Not because you'd lose, but because you'd win and you'd properly destroy them right and quick and hopefully make the news and stuff and wipe the smug smiles off the faces of their lefty fans when they end up having to cut their comics production arms. XD

Blogger Markku October 29, 2017 8:02 PM  

Well, as my article said, they already were beaten by a single individual who apparently didn't even have a real company, and who didn't have a lawyer.

This would probably be the easiest thing that our lawyer has ever done in this professional life...

Blogger Were-Puppy October 29, 2017 8:49 PM  

So the latest palette swap is Valkyrie?
Great. Maybe she is the daughter of the black Heimdall.

Blogger Thucydides October 29, 2017 8:55 PM  

Taking th comic book shop owners with you on a death ride is a pretty cowardly way to go out. I hope a large part of the Alt Hero mission is finding and recruiting comic book shop owners to carry the physical product.

Having a grateful retail channel will undermine the economics of the converged comic book industry.

Blogger tz October 29, 2017 9:20 PM  

I saw yet another trashy trailer for Justice League.
The Flash looks gay. Normally I wouldn't even consider such but there is something creepy about him.
Wonder Woman can't hold it.
Aquaman was A. Blonde, and B. had no power of flight. I'm not sure who/why they have the actor portraying him.
Ben Affleck should reprise Daredevil - well any crusader in a suit.
And I almost forgot
I am the Cy Borg. Resistance is Futile. You won't be pushed to assimilate.

The only upside is the ancient hardcopies are still there and not subject to the current cultural vandalism.

Anonymous Laz October 29, 2017 9:46 PM  

@tz: Aquaman= Jason Momoa. He's the beefcake.

Blogger Michael Maier October 29, 2017 10:56 PM  

Frog Thor.

Loki turns Thor into a frog for three or four great issues and they use that as an excuse to ret-con how Mjolnir works?

Not only that, but the only reason Thor is "unworthy" of his hammer is because Nick Fury called him a dick.

Blogger Positive Dennis October 29, 2017 11:09 PM  

Now, no honest Christian would burn a pinch of incense to Caesar, and call him a god, for any amount of money. Not even the threat of death stirs the heart of the martyr." The esteemed Mr Wright is quite wrong about this modern Christianity does this.
From my inactive blog.

Blogger Lazarus October 30, 2017 12:46 AM  

somebody mentioned japanese:

Blogger SirHamster October 30, 2017 3:09 AM  

Michael Maier wrote:Not only that, but the only reason Thor is "unworthy" of his hammer is because Nick Fury called him a dick.

Black disapproval makes you unworthy. But not female disapproval. Sounds misogynist.

Anonymous 8859 ways to be adorable. October 30, 2017 4:04 AM  

The retailer pays rent (or mortgage), lights, staff, and for the shelves themselves. If the manufacturer isn't paying for placement, then the retailer is.

Post a Comment

Rules of the blog
Please do not comment as "Anonymous". Comments by "Anonymous" will be spammed.

<< Home

Newer Posts Older Posts